Independent EV journalism

Charge News Canada Charge News Canada
Subscribe

⚡ The Shop is open — EV accessories shipped to Canada & the U.S.

Tesla code

Details →
Live
Premium Sponsor Telemiq Rewards — Canada’s best EV charging rewards program Up to 21.75 pts/kWh Start earning

policy

tesla

Manitoba Judge Orders Kinew Government to Reveal Who Excluded Tesla from EV Rebate Program

A Manitoba Court of King's Bench judge has ordered the province to disclose who decided to remove Tesla from the EV rebate program — and why — calling the government's refusal 'baffling coyness.'

By Charge News Canada Newsroom 4 min read
Manitoba Judge Orders Kinew Government to Reveal Who Excluded Tesla from EV Rebate Program

A Manitoba judge has taken what she called an "exceptional and unusual" step: ordering the NDP government to disclose who made the decision to exclude Tesla Motors Canada from the province's electric-vehicle rebate program — and to explain why. The order, issued November 13 by Court of King's Bench Justice Elissa Neville, gives the province 10 days to produce "a complete record" of the decision-making process that disqualified anyone who bought a Tesla after March 19, 2025, from Manitoba's EV rebates, according to CBC News.

What the court order says

In the order, Justice Neville said she cannot make any determination about whether the exclusion is reviewable without knowing who made the decision. She said the province has displayed "a baffling coyness" about the process:

  • The deadline: the government must file its record by way of affidavit within 10 days of the order
  • The gap: "The disputed record filed with the court sheds no light whatsoever on the question of who made the Tesla exclusion decisions, how they made the decisions, why they made the decisions, and whether these decisions are reviewable," Neville wrote
  • The remedy: "I acknowledge that compelling the respondents to file their record by way of an affidavit is an exceptional and unusual remedy," she wrote, but in this case it is "the more practical and efficient means of ensuring that there is a clear and streamlined record before the court"

How the dispute started

Manitoba's EV rebate program rolled out in 2024, retroactive to 2023: a $4,000 rebate for new electric or plug-in hybrid vehicles under $70,000, $2,500 for used EVs, and $1,000 for leased EVs. On provincial budget day in 2025, Finance Minister Adrien Sala said removing Tesla was about "Trump-proofing our economy" and a "commitment to be elbows up." Chinese EVs were excluded at the same time. Tesla asked the court in May to overturn the exclusion, and the province has argued the exclusion cannot be reviewed because it was a funding decision made under the government's spending power.

Why it matters for Canadian EV buyers

Tesla has argued the exclusion cost Manitoba consumers $560,000 and ran counter to the stated purpose of the rebate program. During an October hearing, the company's counsel also cited Premier Wab Kinew's 2025 remark that Elon Musk should "get Donald Trump to stop the tariffs, and then we can talk about the EV rebate." A government motion to strike Tesla's application will be heard at the same time as the application itself. The NDP government declined to comment.

For Manitoban EV shoppers, the outcome could determine whether Tesla buyers purchased after March 19, 2025 regain access to a program that paid $4,000 on eligible new vehicles — and it sets a precedent for how provincial rebate programs can be challenged in court.

Looking for EV deals, insurance, or financing? Check out our partner deals and offers.

If you found this guide helpful, use our Tesla referral link for free Supercharging credits on a new Tesla purchase or lease in Canada.

Charge News Canada uses affiliate links, which means we may earn a commission if you make a purchase through them, at no additional cost to you. Thank you for your support.

Was this useful? Rate it

Stellantis Offers to Repay Brampton Funding as Plant Sale to Roshel Sparks Political Backlash

Next story · swipe left

Next story

Stellantis Offers to Repay Brampton Funding as Plant Sale to Roshel Sparks Political Backlash

4 min read

Prime Minister Carney calls the Brampton plant sale a 'betrayal of workers.' Stellantis offers to return government support; 2,000+ laid-off Ontario workers await resolution as Joly meets all parties Thursday.

The Charge Brief

Get Canada’s EV transition in your inbox

One email a day. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Share

More in policy